Lt. Gen. Moshe Ya'alon Bloggers Call

Lt. Gen. Moshe Yaalon, who served as Chief of Staff of the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) from 2002 to 2005, after serving as Deputy Chief of Staff from 2000 to 2002 -- and who was thus at the top of the IDF for the entire post-Oslo war, before Ariel Sharon reversed course -- spent more than an hour today on a bloggers conference call organized and chaired by Allen Roth of One Jerusalem.  There is a good summary of the call there.

Yaalon repeated several times that the outcome of the Hezbollah War was the result of mismanagement by the political and senior military levels (who he thinks should resign), not a result of lack of IDF capability.  He said the IDF called up more people to manage the Gaza disengagement than it did for the war in Lebanon.  Not even 10% of the IDF forces were used.

He does think that significant damage was done to Hezbollah.  They had 500-600 casualties, a huge amount for an organization based on 1,000 elite fighters.  Almost all of the long and medium range rocket launchers were destroyed, even though thousands of Kytushas remain.  He does not think that Nasrallah currently has the capability to renew hostilities, because it will take time to be ready, “but when they are ready, they will do it.”

He believes the root cause of the situation is not the occupation of the West Bank, but rather an Iranian goal to implement an “Islamofascist ideology” (his term) and that Israel deceived itself into thinking that territorial compromise was a solution.  After prior withdrawals resulted in the creation of Hezbollahstan and Hamastan (his terms), to think now about withdrawing from the West Bank “is to be blind.”  He thinks military operations in Gaza should be intensified, and that Israel should retake control of the Philadelphi corridor.

Ultimately, he said, there is no chance to reach any stability in the region without confronting Iran, who is behind the situation in Iraq, the situation in Lebanon, and the situation with the Palestinians, and who is also seeking to undermine the moderate Arab regimes in the region.  And despite being the mastermind behind the conflict, Iran has so far paid no price for its actions.  He repeated in the call yesterday something he has written before:

Senator John McCain said recently: “There is only one thing worse than the U.S. exercising a military option, and that is a nuclear-armed Iran.” I agree with him. But before going to the military option, Iran must be isolated politically and economically; the military option can be used only when these methods have been exhausted.

But the most stunning part of the call came in his answer to the question of Jerry Gordon of Israpundit about the existence of corruption in Israel.  Ya’alon said the subject could consume “another conference call” and that he worried “more about this phenomenon than the Iranian threat.”  He views it as “the most important challenge” facing Israel, and that it has accounted for the mismanagement and incompetence of Israeli leadership.

His comments reminded me of one of the most remarkable portions of Benjamin Netanyahu’s remarkable interview last March with Ari Shavit of Haaretz:, which included this passage:

Of late there is more and more talk about corruption. You were prime minister, you were finance minister. Is Israel a corrupt country?

"There is corruption in Israel. It is increasing. In the past few years it has been growing and deepening at a dizzying pace. But those who talk about corruption are generally off-target. They talk about the connection between the member of [a party's] central committee and the politician who gets him a job in order to win his support. But that is a relatively minor phenomenon, and even when it happens, its material scope is limited. Therefore I say that this is only the tip of the corruption iceberg. It is the less important 10 percent that is above the water. The more serious corruption is below the surface. It is hardly talked about; it is hardly known about. But it is the truly worrisome corruption, it is the true danger."

Shavit returned to the subject later in the interview:

Has the corruption in Israel become worse in recent years?

"Unequivocally, yes. Look at the international indices that examine corruption. But at the same time it is important to emphasize that when it comes to the wealth-government connection, most of the owners of capital are not part of that connection. Nor are many of those in government. But between a small group of the wealthy and a certain group of people in power, there is a connection on an astounding scale. And therefore I say that corruption has become a cancer. It is a millstone on the economy. It is hindering growth and it is liable to develop to Argentine dimensions. Argentina is a very rich country that stagnated economically because the corruption there became a curse. Once a country sinks into the quagmire of corruption, it is very difficult to get out of it."

My principal thought after yesterday’s call is how different things would have been had Israel’s leadership at a moment of trial been Netanyahu, Sharansky, and Ya’alon -- all of whom left the government or were removed from it as a result of the disengagement plan -- instead of Olmert, Peretz and Halutz. 

Fortunately, in a democracy, these things can be corrected.

(Be sure to check out Westbankmama’s excellent post on the call as well.  In response to a question from Anne Lieberman of Boker tov, Boulder! about what caused Sharon's disengagement reversal, Ya'alon said he had an English translation of an article he wrote in Hebrew, and will provide it to One Jerusalem; it should be worth reading).

UPDATE: Boker tov, Boulder! has a very perceptive post on the call. Atlas Shrugs has a good post and a transcript (how does she do that?). Brian of London participated in the call in a Starbucks across from Scotland Yard. Gateway Pundit’s post is here.

Comments

[RR]

For a lengthy two-part Ari Shavit interview of Ya’alon, go here (http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/pages/ShArt.jhtml?itemNo=202714&contrassID=2&subContrassID=14&sbSubContrassID=0&listSrc=Y) and here ( http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/pages/ShArt.jhtml?itemNo=202706&contrassID=2&subContrassID=14&sbSubContrassID=0&listSrc=Y).

[westbankmama]

Thank you for the link.

[David Ben-Ariel]

Ehud Olmert Playing with German Fire
http://ezinearticles.com/?&id=260831

God Save Us From Islam and Europe!
http://ezinearticles.com/?&id=265812

Europe to Take Out Iran for Jerusalem
http://ezinearticles.com/?&id=159523

[FERN SIDMAN]

THE ABANDONMENT OF OUR BROTHERS

BY: FERN SIDMAN

Now that the recent decision has been made to lift the Israeli naval blockade of Lebanon, we can only interpret this move as the final nail in the coffin in the already moribund Israeli strategy concerning the release of the three Israeli kidnapped soldiers. As of now, Hamas and Hezbollah have not released any signs of life from Gilad Shalit, Edud Goldwasser and Eldad Regev. If these men are alive, the Israeli government has virtually abandoned them.

It is yet the latest phase in the otherwise abysmally impotent and incompetent policy of the Olmert administration. As we know, the Olmert government failed to formulate a successful military strategy in Lebanon, thereby achieving none of its stated objectives, leaving Israel in the wake of its worst military defeat since the creation of the state. Throughout the war, the Olmert government was riddled with hesitation, confusion and internal strife. More to the point, this military defeat places Israel in even greater danger in the future. Hezbollah and Hamas now can carry on further kidnappings of Israeli soldiers with impunity, while developing the military strength to do even greater damage to Israel. If this time around, the city of Tel Aviv was not the recipient of Katyusha rocket attacks, there is a greater possibility that down the road, more deadly and lethal military hardware will be developed that will indeed wreak great havoc, destruction and devastation. It is only a matter of time.

It is no wonder that there are calls for the immediate resignation of the entire Olmert government. If there has been any unifying factor in Israel as of late, it has been calls from both the far left and right for the Olmert government to resign. Seems like the only one satisfied with Olmert's performance during the war is none other than Hezbollah leader, Hassan Nasrallah, who stated, ""If we have to choose between a foolish prime minister and another who is strong and capable, we prefer that the fool remain,” he told Lebanese Al-Safir newspaper Tuesday. Nasrallah made the comments when asked about the prime minister’s recent claims - themselves based on Nasrallah’s statements - that Israel had won the war. (Arutz Sheva - 9/7/06)

Last night in Tel Aviv over 40,000 Israelis protested against the Olmert government, demanding the formation of a state commission of inquiry of improprieties during the war. This protest was organized by Israeli army reservists who have been continually keeping a political fire under the Olmert government since the cease fire had been announced. They were joined in the outcry against the government by retired Meretz Party chairman Yossi Sarid, senior reserve officers and relatives of soldiers who fell during the war.

Under the banner Movement for Quality Government (MQG), the group is calling for a state commission to examine the government’s actions, while the reservists have been calling for the resignation of the top government officials for their management of the recent war in Lebanon.

According to an Arutz Sheva report of the protest, Eliad Shraga, chairman of the MQG stated, “The Prime Minister must open his eyes and realize that a state commission of inquiry is needed."

Also speaking at the protest were former Defense Minister Moshe Arens of the Likud, retired Meretz Party chairman Yossi Sarid, senior reserves officers and relatives of soldiers who fell during the war.

“It is unacceptable that those under investigation appoint the investigators,” Arens told the crowd. “Only a state commission of inquiry will examine in a thorough manner the decision of the government in the last war in Lebanon. Never have there been such confusing and contradictory orders issued in the handling of a war.”

“If we continue to remain silent, we will be hit with another bomb,” Movement For Quality Government spokesman Shuki Levanon said. He added that Prime Minister Ehud Olmert had been invited to the protest, “to declare from this podium that he has heard the will of the people and will establish a state commission – but the chicken didn’t even answer.”

Just last week, in the same location in Tel Aviv, hundreds of thousands of Israelis demanded that the Olmert government secure the release of the three kidnapped soldiers, yet this cry of anguish has fallen on deaf ears. Within days of the protest, the government of Israel issued the order the lift the naval blockade of Lebanon. The government has thus far made no viable attempts to ensure the safe release of the kidnapped soldiers.

It is a government that has abandoned its people and its brothers. It is a government that is immersed in internal corruption, conflict and scandal. It is a government that suffers from a terminal case of inexhaustable loquaciousness, yet takes no actions in protecting its citizens or soldiers.

The demand for the resignation of the Olmert government has also been spotlighted in the Israeli media and the pressure is mounting at a rapid pace. It is time for the world Jewish community to weigh in on this most critical issue. We are a nation without real leadership, during a time when real and authentic leaders are so desperately needed. Leaders who will display the strength and fortitude it takes to devise a concrete plan to bring our kidnapped soldiers home and to deal with terrorism on both fronts with swift and decisive measures. We need leaders who can and will elevate a nation from its collective despair and loss of morale.

Silence on the part of world Jewry at this moment of paramount importance in the history of the Jewish nation is totally unacceptable and is equivalent to blatant apathy and indifference.
While anti-Semitism has reached epidemic proportions throughout the world, since the beginning of the war, particularly in England and Australia, it does not behoove the international Jewish community to remain silent. We are living in precarious times, times that do not bode well for the State of Israel and the Jews worldwide.

The time has come to realize that world Jewry must summon up the strength and courage to seize this moment while it still can. It is time to demand that the leadership of Israel be placed in the hands of those whose platform is the belief in the Almighty G-d of Israel and scrupulous adherence to Torah principles. Without Torah leadership, we are left with a leadership vacuum that can only lead to more destruction and deadly consequences for the future of Israel and the Jewish people.

As we approach the 16th yahrzeit of Rabbi Meir Kahane, ZTK"L let us take this time to remember his words of wisdom, vision and foresight. It was Rabbi Kahane who said, "The obligation to listen to, obey and respect the authority of government rests upon whether that government, in a particular case, is itself obeying the Torah, the need of the people". (Israel: Revolution or Referendum?, 1990, p.95)

It was Rabbi Kahane who also said, "No government, including the Israeli one, has any right to protest when - because of its failure to carry out its elementary duty to protect its citizens - individual Jews, who fear for their lives and future, rise up and act in self defense". (Israel: Revolution or Referendum?, 1990, p.118)

It is time to heed these words. In this month of Elul, we must seek to become closer to our Creator, to beseech Him to allow us to return to His holy Torah. It is a time to immerse ourselves in fervent prayer, to examine our deeds and misdeeds and to rectify them.It is time to reach out to our brothers in kindness and compassion. It is time to speak out against those in leadership who cannot and will not lead. It is time to demand a return to G-d. This is our only path to salvation as a people and as a nation. Our date of redemption is coming closer as we are in the midst of "Chevlei Moshiach", the birth pangs of our holy Redeemer. Our future is inextricably tied to our efforts to infuse ourselves and our leadership with true Torah values.

May we always remember the words of the sweet singer of Israel, King David who said, "Teach me the way, Oh G-d, that I may walk in Your Truth". (Psalms)